by Richard Ruelas - Sept. 15, 2012 10:53 PM
The Republic | azcentral.com
Read more: http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/20120904shaken-baby-fatalities-doubts.html#ixzz26caFCTUv
Drayton Witt kept insisting he had nothing to do with the death of his 4-month-old baby. He said it the night he brought the near-comatose infant into the emergency room on June 1, 2000. He said it during his sentencing, following his conviction on murdering the boy by shaking him. And he was still proclaiming his innocence as he started serving his 20-year sentence in 2002.
His lamentations didn't gain legal and medical weight until 2012. The Arizona Justice Project, a volunteer group of attorneys, filed a motion to toss out his murder conviction based on the evolving science around what was known as shaken-baby syndrome. The state did not file an argument in response. Witt was released on May 31, becoming the second Arizonan in the last two years to see his guilty verdict in a shaken-baby case erased.
Among those who helped secure Witt's freedom was the 97-year-old British pediatric neurosurgeon who, in 1971, first identified the trio of telltale symptoms that became accepted as proof that a baby had been violently shaken. Attorneys also secured a sworn statement from the medical examiner who originally ruled the baby died from being shaken. His revised conclusion was that the baby died of a disease.
Fifteen months earlier, in February 2011, a Buckeye man named Armando Castillo, 42, had his conviction overturned in the 1998 death of a toddler. Like Witt, Castillo maintained his innocence throughout. And, like Witt, Castillo would be imprisoned a long time before attorneys found medical evidence to back up his story.
In both cases, judges ruled that a jury would likely acquit each man after hearing the new medical understanding of the evidence.
The overturned convictions didn't erase the charges, just sent the cases back for a possible retrial. Prosecutors decided to keep pursuing murder charges in both cases. Castillo pleaded guilty to a reduced charge to avoid the risk of a retrial. Witt's murder trial is scheduled for 2013.
Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery said that his office still believes that Witt was responsible for the death of the 4-month-old baby boy. "Obviously, we believed it the first time around," Montgomery said.
He said prosecutors now focus more on proving that a child was injured, not necessarily that he was shaken. Montgomery said speculation that suspected abused children died from diseases was just defense-attorney theories.
"I think we're still looking at cases where children were injured," Montgomery said. "How we prove that may change."
That's because a growing body of medical and legal experts, nationally and internationally, are casting doubt on what became known as shaken-baby syndrome. Pediatric neurologists and forensic pathologists say the long-held triad of symptoms -- bleeding on the brain, swelling of the brain and bleeding in the eyes -- thought to indicate a baby was violently and intentionally shaken could also be caused by a host of diseases, including infections.
DePaul University law professor Deborah Tuerkheimer, who wrote a 2009 study on the use of shaken-baby syndrome in courtrooms, said the easily spotted symptoms became not only a medical diagnosis but also a legal tool adopted quickly and used convincingly in courtrooms nationwide.
Physicians would testify that a shaken child would become unresponsive or go limp almost immediately after the abuse. So the last adult with the child would be the primary suspect. And the shaken-baby diagnosis also provided a motive: a frustrated caregiver looking to quiet a crying child.
Some shaken-baby cases included other signs of violent abuse, such as broken bones, bruises or fractures. But others, like in Witt's case, had no outward signs of injuries. Cases were built solely on the symptoms of shaken-baby syndrome.
"(The syndrome) did all of the work," Tuerkheimer said. Jurors would hear the experts testify with certainty and couple that with an "inclination to want to convict and hold someone responsible for such an awful outcome," she said.
In the last half of the 1990s, the Maricopa County Attorney's Office handled shaken-baby cases at the rate of two a week. During one stretch, it had a conviction rate, in non-fatal cases, of 84 percent.
Tuerkheimer said many of the defendants were convicted in emotional trials, while others took plea deals because they saw little chance of winning. She said there's no way to know whether the Witt and Castillo cases are isolated wrongful convictions or signs of a systemic flaw that will produce hundreds of reversals.
"No one has any sense of the numbers here," Tuerkheimer said.
Witt knows he is No. 2, the second shaken-baby conviction in Arizona to be vacated. But he figures the pattern that police and prosecutors followed in his case was repeated many more times.
"The system is flawed," he said. "I'm sure there's a lot of people like that."
* * *
Maria Holt's baby son, Steven, was just shy of being 5 months old on June 1, 2000. Dressed in a blue and white onesie, he slept in his car seat as Witt dropped Holt off for her evening shift as a waitress at the Bill Johnson's Big Apple restaurant in north Phoenix.
Witt, then 18, and Holt, then 20, had been boyfriend and girlfriend since they'd met two years before, but Steven had been conceived with another man during a breakup. Regardless, Witt saw the baby as his son; he was in the delivery room when Steven was born, and the child carried his last name. It was routine for Witt to care for Steven when Holt was at work; she often called home between tables to check in.
During one call around 8 or 9 that night, Witt told Holt he thought Steven might have had another seizure. His eyes appeared odd, Witt said, and he was fussy. Holt said to come get her at the restaurant and they would take the baby to the emergency room.
Steven had been a sickly baby, in and out of the hospital three times during his short life, including a six-day stay at Phoenix Children's Hospital just a month earlier when doctors couldn't get a bead on what was causing the baby's vomiting and seizures.
On this night, the boy stopped breathing during the 6-mile drive from the restaurant to Paradise Valley Hospital. Witt pulled over and climbed into the back seat to perform CPR while Holt took the wheel. At the hospital, doctors worked to get Steven breathing again. Then the baby's heart stopped. It took them about 30 minutes to stabilize him, after which he was flown to Phoenix Children's Hospital.
A doctor at Paradise Valley Hospital, in a report, diagnosed the cardiac arrest and said the baby was suffering from dehydration and possibly sepsis, a severe reaction to bacteria. He also expressed concern about brain injury caused by dehydration, too much acid in the blood, and not enough oxygen. There was no mention of suspected abuse.
Witt and Holt left Paradise Valley Hospital to drive to Phoenix Children's. Expecting another long hospital stay, they stopped by their home to pick up extra clothes.
* * *
The idea that violent shaking of infants could cause brain injury was first proposed in a medical-journal article in 1971. Not only did it gain acceptance in the medical community over the next two decades, it also seeped into popular culture. Child-abuse prevention groups started awareness campaigns; the phrase "shaken-baby syndrome" entered the Random House dictionary in 1996.
By 2001, the American Academy of Pediatrics produced a position paper on shaken-baby syndrome, saying that doctors should presume abuse in any baby under a year old who had head injuries absent obvious trauma, such as a car accident. The paper, published in the journal Pediatrics, said the "constellation" of injuries in a shaken baby could not result from an accidental trip or fall.
The article also offered a psychological profile of adults who shake a child. "Such shaking often results from tension and frustration generated by a baby's crying or irritability," the journal article said, "yet crying is not a legal justification for such violence." It went on to warn that shaken babies were often misdiagnosed, meaning doctors needed to be extremely vigilant to spot them.
After Steven arrived at Phoenix Children's Hospital, a doctor who evaluated him wrote that the baby had no bruising or skull deformities, but showed some bleeding in the eyes. The doctor also noted that "the infant is flaccid. There is no response to pain."
At 3 a.m., a pediatrician wrote on a progress report that the baby's symptoms "raise the possibility of non-accidental trauma."
Medical records show doctors knew their infant patient had been at the hospital a month before for projectile vomiting and flulike symptoms. But by 7 a.m., doctors felt sure of what they were looking at.
"The findings are most consistent with shaken baby, plus or minus hypoxia injury," read a doctor's progress report on the case. Hypoxia refers to an injury caused by lack of oxygen.
Steven's condition did not improve. At noon, doctors declared him brain dead. One wrote the following: "Mom is currently hugging the patient and we are planning to withdraw support and allow him to progress to cardiac death later on this afternoon. The police have been notified of the findings."
Steven was pronounced dead at 3:30 p.m. on June 2.
* * *
In a case where shaken-baby syndrome seems a possibility, events quickly and simultaneously move along parallel tracks: doctors working to save a baby, police working to find a suspect.
But once doctors and police believe they are dealing with a shaken-baby case, they often ignore evidence that might suggest a different reason for a baby's illness, said Christina Rubalcava, an attorney with the Arizona Justice Project.
"You're already locked in to what it is," said Rubalcava, an attorney with Osborn Maledon who volunteered her time on the Witt case. She says that in general, once a doctor sees the triad of symptoms, a call to child-welfare agencies and police becomes automatic. The belief in shaken-baby syndrome "is like gospel to them," she said.
But Kathy Coffman, a pediatrician at Phoenix Children's Hospital who specializes in abuse cases, denied that doctors automatically diagnose shaking and ignore disease or infections or other causes. "We go through all the factors to make sure we're not missing something," Coffman said.
Coffman, a pediatrician for 20 years, was not at Phoenix Children's Hospital when Steven was treated and would not comment specifically on this case. She now is the medical director of a specialized unit at the hospital, made up of doctors and social workers, that handles suspected cases of abuse. "I don't think anybody who works in this field, law enforcement or anybody, is cavalier about making these calls," she said.
"The absolute last thing I want to do," she said, "is have someone go to prison for something they didn't do."
In the early morning hours of June 2, Phoenix police interviewed Witt and Holt as they sat in a room near their child. The questions seemed accusatory from the start, Witt said, and he ended the interview. A worker with the state's child-protection agency, in a report written later that morning, would say officers described Witt as "short-tempered and volatile."
After Steven died and Witt and Holt were leaving the hospital to go home, they found their car missing; police had seized it from the parking lot to search it for possible evidence. Friends drove them home, where they found two officers, armed with a warrant, who had been searching the trailer since 11:30 a.m. -- 4 hours before Steven died -- to find evidence to build a case.
"One thing after another," Holt said. "It's heartbreaking."
The police left at 9:30 p.m. They had pulled up carpet samples and took some baby items. The next day, officers knocked on the door and asked to take Witt in for questioning.
"Let's go," Witt said. "I ain't got nothing to hide."
Witt is a man of few words and didn't offer many to police. When detectives questioned him about what happened to the baby, Witt replied that he didn't know and that they should ask the doctors.
Witt was booked into jail on charges of first-degree murder and child abuse. He would remain jailed until his trial.
Holt said the arrest was devastating. "I lose my son, and then I lose the man who's done nothing but love me and love my son," she said. She had support from her extended family but felt some friends slip away. When she visited Witt in jail, which was often, she worked to buoy his spirits: "You'll be home soon," she would say. "This is just a misunderstanding. We know the truth."
Witt had a public defender who tried to get a plea deal, but Witt refused to take it. "When they arrested me, I figured somewhere down the line they'd come to their senses and figure out the right stuff," Witt said. "But clearly they didn't."
The trial started in February 2002.
"Steven Witt lived only five months," the prosecutor, Dyanne Greer, told the jury in her opening statement, according to a transcript. "He died as the result of violent, severe shaking. ... He died at the hands of a person who was supposed to be the caretaker ... and that man, ladies and gentlemen, is Drayton Witt."
Holt was called to the stand; she would be the first witness. It would be her job to tell the couple's story: how they "just clicked" when they first met through a friend; how Holt's extremely protective dog immediately warmed up to Witt; how, when she became pregnant by another man, Witt treated the child as if he were his own. She also told the jury about the baby's history of illnesses and hospitalizations, which included a respiratory infection, pneumonia, seizures and vomiting, and how the medicine he was given only seemed to make him worse.
After Holt, four doctors and the medical examiner took the stand. Each testified that Steven's injuries were most likely caused by shaking. To the jury, the evidence would have seemed strong and specific: The boy had certain injuries that, in the absence of major trauma, were possible only if he had been shaken violently. And the narrow, medically accepted time frame of the onset of the baby's symptoms pointed to Witt.
Witt, seated at the defense table, still held out hope. But his defense attorney called only one expert to cast doubt on whether the injuries were caused by shaking. Karen Griest, a forensic pediatric pathologist and former New Mexico coroner, said that "shaken-baby syndrome is sort of a hot topic of debate in the medical community. It's sort of an evolving process to figure out what is going on."
In closing arguments, the prosecutor painted a picture for the jury of Witt shaking the child.
"The defendant knowingly grabbed Steven, shook him so violently that he started to seize," Greer said. "Drayton had to know that Steven was being violently injured while he was shaking him to death, inches in front of his face," she said.
Jurors found Witt guilty of second-degree murder. When it came time for Witt's sentencing in April 2002, he told the judge that although he had been an unruly teenager, he had turned his life around with Holt and Steven. But he was not apologetic.
"I am not sorry, for I didn't do no wrong," Witt said, according to a transcript of the hearing. "I came up here to tell you how much my son meant to me."
The judge sentenced him to 20 years.
* * *
Though Witt asked for protective custody in prison, he said the request was denied, and he was put into the general inmate population. Three years into his sentence, he was attacked in the recreation yard by three men with improvised knives. Witt tucked himself into a ball and tried to cover his head, but said he was stabbed some 70 times before it was over. Ten of those wounds went through one or the other of his hands.
Witt was flown to a Flagstaff hospital, where doctors did surgery to repair his hands. Holt was at work when she got the call from Witt's parents telling her of the attack. When she saw him in his hospital bed, she knew they had to get married.
"Just wanting to make sure that he knew that I was there," she said. "And no matter what, he knew that if it came to 2020, I might be old and gray, but that I would be the one standing by that gate (waiting) for him to come home."
The wedding was in September 2006. The groom wore orange, his "carrot suit," as Witt called it. Prison rules dictate what a bride may wear: A wedding dress must have a neckline above the collarbone and sleeves that cover the arms. And no orange; that color is reserved for inmates. In the end, Holt just bought a dress she liked -- it was maroon -- and pulled a T-shirt over it during the ceremony to cover enough bare skin.
Tradition endures even in the strangest of settings. Witt said he paced in his cell nervously before the ceremony, held just before visiting hours. He would get to wear his wedding band in prison, but the bride had to provide prison officials proof of purchase. Guards did allow the groom to kiss the bride.
"It's emotional, no matter what," Holt said.
At the time of the wedding, all of Witt's appeals had been denied and exhausted. It appeared he would be in prison until 2020.
* * *
In 2009, Deborah Tuerkheimer published her paper, "The Next Innocence Project: Shaken Baby Syndrome and the Criminal Courts" in the Washington University Law Review.
"In its classic formulation, SBS comes as close as one could imagine to a medical diagnosis of murder," Tuerkheimer wrote. "Prosecutors use it to prove the mechanism of death, the intent to harm, and the identity of the killer."
Also that year, the American Academy of Pediatrics revised its position paper on shaken-baby syndrome. It urged physicians to stop using that term and instead describe injuries as "abusive head trauma." The group said it urged adoption of the "less mechanistic term" to stop the focus on shaking. Instead, the journal said, doctors should look at a wider range of possible causes.
Witt's prison records show that he was a model inmate after his marriage. He had been moved into protective custody following his assault. While there, he met Armando Castillo, another man who had been convicted of shaking a child to death.
The Arizona Justice Project filed its motion in Castillo's case in April 2010; his conviction was vacated 10 months later. The project took up Drayton Witt's case in 2011, and the news was a blast of hope, Maria Witt said. "You get that light sparked back in your life."
Those working on Witt's case assembled a list of medical experts who reviewed Steven's autopsy photos and medical records. Most concluded that Steven's death was likely caused by a blockage in the vein that drained blood from his brain.
The attorneys also spotted a letter in the New York Times Magazine from Norman Guthkelch, the British pediatric neurosurgeon who first wrote about the symptoms that indicated a shaken baby. In the letter, a response to an article about the changing medical opinions about shaken-baby syndrome, Guthkelch defended his 1971 paper that concluded babies can get severe brain damage from shaking. The city under Guthkelch's name: Tucson.
The Project attorneys asked Guthkelch to look at the records in the case. He filed an affidavit in support of Witt, which marked his first legal involvement on behalf of a person trying to reverse a shaken-baby conviction.
"The death of Steven Witt is the type of case where a diagnosis of Shaken Baby Syndrome should not have been made," Guthkelch wrote. He said there were too many other possibilities that could explain the baby's death, and that while his process offers a possible explanation for some head injuries, any presumption that an injured child was shaken was a "distortion" of his theory.
Also key to the case was the affidavit of A.L. Mosley, the county medical examiner who performed the autopsy on Steven. Mosley was shown new analysis of his autopsy by doctors who spotted errors in his work. Most notably, doctors said, autopsy photos showed a blocked and swollen vein that was not noted in the report.
Mosley, in his affidavit, concluded that "if I were to testify today, I would state that I believe Steven's death was likely the result of a natural disease process, not (shaken-baby syndrome)."
Witt's attorneys filed the motion in February. The state did not file a response. The judge vacated Witt's conviction and ordered his release.
* * *
The newly cast scientific thought on shaken-baby syndrome is affecting other cases. A 2007 case against Lisa Randall, a day-care operator, originally filed as a death-penalty case, was tossed out before it reached trial. An expert hired by the prosecution in 2010 concluded that the child did not die from shaking as originally thought.
In 2009, prosecutors dropped murder charges against Craig Rettig in a shaken-baby case from 2004. The defendant's lawyer located experts who found that the baby died from striking his head on a coffee table, not from being shaken.
Also, in 2009, Keith Roberts asked that expert testimony about shaken-baby syndrome not be allowed in his trial on charges that he killed his infant son. The Maricopa County Attorney's Office argued that both sides should present their experts and leave it for the jury to decide. The judge agreed. Roberts took a plea offer the day before his trial was scheduled to begin. He was sentenced to eight years in prison.
Witt was released from custody wearing a jail-issued paper suit. He borrowed a cellphone from a passer-by to call his wife. It was 8 a.m. She had been told he wouldn't be released until noon. She broke speed-limit laws driving from the opposite end of town to get him.
Maria Witt said having her husband out of prison is validation.
"To finally have people believe in me," she said, "and be able to start the grieving process and what we missed out on, and be able to start on the life that we missed out on, is more precious than anything."
Drayton Witt, who is working on a construction crew, said he often feels like a modern-day Rip Van Winkle, awakening to find a world where so much is accomplished by cellular phone, or that there are self-checkout lanes at the grocery store.
Witt does not want to take a plea deal like his friend, Castillo, did. He hopes prosecutors drop the case before his trial next year.
He does not blame police or prosecutors for the decade he spent behind bars. He said officers and attorneys were just doing their job. And he always figured the truth would win out.
"You keep screaming," he said. "Eventually, someone will hear you."
Reach the reporter at richard.ruelas@arizonarepublic.com.
Read more: http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/20120904shaken-baby-fatalities-doubts.html#ixzz26ca27TaF
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Sunday, September 16, 2012
Tuesday, June 26, 2012
The breastfeeding mother: Breast milk as a biomarker?
It just never made sense to me, 40 years ago, when my
professors at UNC School of Medicine casually announced human breast
milk contained no vitamin D.
“How can that be? How can that possibly be? That makes no sense,” I thought. “Was primitive man supposed to give their infants vitamin D pills that didn’t even exist?”
I have written before about biomarkers, such as:
How high does the breastfeeding mom’s vitamin D level need to be for her infant to get natural vitamin D levels? This level is a biomarker because it gives us insight on how high vitamin D levels were for species survival. If the breastfeeding mom couldn’t supply vitamin D to the infant, our species may not have survived. Whatever vitamin D level that might be, that would be the level humans evolved to have.
Professors Wagner and Hollis and colleagues did an elegant randomized controlled trial 6 years ago that we have covered before, but it should be covered often. They simply gave two different doses of vitamin D to nursing mothers and measured the vitamin D levels of their infants and mothers. They used a small sample of breast feeding women, giving half the women a prenatal vitamin (containing 400 IU) and the other half a prenatal vitamin plus an extra 6,000 IU/day of vitamin D.
The suckling infants of the mothers given only the prenatal were also given 300 IU of vitamin D directly (it would have been unethical to deprive any of the infants of vitamin D). They noted no side effects with any dose, but the 6,000 IU/day arm of the study answered my 40-year-old question.
Wagner CL, Hulsey TC, Fanning D, Ebeling M, Hollis BW. High-dose vitamin D3 supplementation in a cohort of breastfeeding mothers and their infants: a 6-month follow-up pilot study. Breastfeed Med. 2006 Summer;1(2):59-70.
The 6,000 IU/day dose of vitamin D did three things.
I’d like to reiterate, can you think of a better biomarker for how much vitamin D humans need?
Further reading:
“How can that be? How can that possibly be? That makes no sense,” I thought. “Was primitive man supposed to give their infants vitamin D pills that didn’t even exist?”
I have written before about biomarkers, such as:
- How high does your vitamin D level have to be to maximally suppress parathyroid hormone?
- How high does your vitamin D level have to be to maximally improve calcium absorption?
- How high does your vitamin D level have to be to prevent abnormal bones?
How high does the breastfeeding mom’s vitamin D level need to be for her infant to get natural vitamin D levels? This level is a biomarker because it gives us insight on how high vitamin D levels were for species survival. If the breastfeeding mom couldn’t supply vitamin D to the infant, our species may not have survived. Whatever vitamin D level that might be, that would be the level humans evolved to have.
Professors Wagner and Hollis and colleagues did an elegant randomized controlled trial 6 years ago that we have covered before, but it should be covered often. They simply gave two different doses of vitamin D to nursing mothers and measured the vitamin D levels of their infants and mothers. They used a small sample of breast feeding women, giving half the women a prenatal vitamin (containing 400 IU) and the other half a prenatal vitamin plus an extra 6,000 IU/day of vitamin D.
The suckling infants of the mothers given only the prenatal were also given 300 IU of vitamin D directly (it would have been unethical to deprive any of the infants of vitamin D). They noted no side effects with any dose, but the 6,000 IU/day arm of the study answered my 40-year-old question.
Wagner CL, Hulsey TC, Fanning D, Ebeling M, Hollis BW. High-dose vitamin D3 supplementation in a cohort of breastfeeding mothers and their infants: a 6-month follow-up pilot study. Breastfeed Med. 2006 Summer;1(2):59-70.
The 6,000 IU/day dose of vitamin D did three things.
- It gave the mothers natural vitamin D levels (50 ng/ml or close to).
- It transformed breast milk into a rich source of vitamin D.
- It gave suckling infants natural blood levels of vitamin D (45 ng/ml).
- Take a loading dose of 10,000 IU/day for a month.
- After one month on 10,000 IU/day, stop supplementing your infant with vitamin D as your breast milk should now be filled with vitamin D.
- Take 6,000 IU/day maintenance dose thereafter, except on days you get full body sun exposure.
I’d like to reiterate, can you think of a better biomarker for how much vitamin D humans need?
- “How much vitamin D do human breast–feeding mothers have to take to transform their breast milk into an adequate source of vitamin D for their infants?”
Further reading:
About John Cannell, MD
Dr. John Cannell is founder of the Vitamin D Council. He has written many peer-reviewed papers on vitamin D and speaks frequently across the United States on the subject. Dr. Cannell holds an M.D. and has served the medical field as a general practitioner, itinerant emergency physician, and psychiatrist.Saturday, March 17, 2012
Experts recommend vitamin D blood testing for all children
Updated: 2012-02-23 16:44:24 CST Category: Vitamin D Deficiency-Diagnosis and Treatment
The group pointed to studies, which have indicated that 10 percent of U.S. children may have vitamin D deficiency and another 60 percent have insufficient levels of the nutrient. This is a serious problem because deficiency can lead to decreased bone density, stunted growth, metabolic dysfunction and cardiovascular issues.
Given the fact that the sun is the primary source of vitamin D, parents and pediatricians are urged to be extra vigilant against the problem during the winter months, when sun exposure tends to drop.
"Vitamin D deficiency can be a problem year round, but because sun exposure is critical for vitamin D synthesis and production, the winter months further exacerbate what is a perennial problem," said Dominique Long, a pediatric endocrinologist at Johns Hopkins.
A child's vitamin D levels can be assessed relatively easily with a simple blood test.
Thursday, March 15, 2012
9000 visits! Sharing is Caring
WOW! 9000! Thanks for taking the time to visit our blog. There are so many important things going on here, and if you are reading what we have to say, it may save you a lot of hassle. Vitamin D is so very important, and for those who still don't know much about it, definitely do as much research as you can. If you're pregnant take vitamin D supplements. Give your children Vitamin D supplements! Vitamin D is not only very important for bone health, but many studies are showing that it plays a role in many different things including SIDS, Depression, MS, Autism, and so much more!
We also have shared our story and the nightmare we're going through. If you haven't read it yet, visit Our Story. We've talked to so many doctors, and most agree that things have gone WAY too far! We've contacted politicians, we've contacted schools, we've even gone to the media now. If you know someone else who is suffering from false allegations of child abuse, have them e-mail me their story and I'll do my best to share it too. Thank You.
We also have shared our story and the nightmare we're going through. If you haven't read it yet, visit Our Story. We've talked to so many doctors, and most agree that things have gone WAY too far! We've contacted politicians, we've contacted schools, we've even gone to the media now. If you know someone else who is suffering from false allegations of child abuse, have them e-mail me their story and I'll do my best to share it too. Thank You.
Doctor queries shaken baby symptoms
Melissa Davey
March 16, 2012Request free informational DVD on how to win back your walk from TBI
Colin Smith, a senior lecturer in pathology at the University of Edinburgh, urged doctors to be more open-minded when assessing children with traumatic brain injuries.
His comments come as 145 incidents of a baby being shaken were reported to the NSW Department of Community Services in 2010-11, compared with 133 the year before - though many doctors believe the condition is under-diagnosed.
Advertisement: Story continues below
When three symptoms occurred together - blood between the brain and the skull, retinal rupture and brain swelling - doctors usually concluded the baby had been violently shaken, Dr Smith told the annual conference of the Royal College of Pathologists of Australasia last week.But there was growing evidence other conditions, such as lack of blood flow to the brain from a seizure or breathing obstruction, could cause similar injury. ''What was considered to be absolute fact and a guarantee of conviction is now much more circumspect,'' he said.
''Those injuries and their relationship with head injury have been challenged by scientific, peer-reviewed literature.''
Doctors were trained to diagnose shaken baby syndrome until proven otherwise, he said, and may have difficulty accepting alternative explanations.
''They see the triad of injuries and don't question it,'' he said. ''It is also very hard to differentiate between deliberate and accidental trauma.
Julie Fordham, an associate professor of forensic science at the University of Western Australia and a criminal lawyer, said wrongful convictions happened ''frequently enough to be worried about''.
''Some people do kill their babies,'' she said. ''But you can't unjustly convict someone either, based on science that is in a constant state of flux.''
Dr Terry Donald, a child protection and forensic paediatrician at the Women's and Children's Hospital in Adelaide, said that while experienced doctors were sometimes more circumspect about the cause of head injury in young children, it was ''quite legitimate'' for less experienced doctors to be concerned by those same injuries.
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/national/health/doctor-queries-shaken-baby-symptoms-20120315-1v86t.html#ixzz1pDFwizgl
Sunday, March 11, 2012
COMMON PEDIATRIC BONE DISEASES-APPROACH TO PATHOLOGICAL FRACTURES
COMMON PEDIATRIC BONE DISEASES-APPROACH TO PATHOLOGICAL FRACTURES
Click for pdf: Common pediatric bone diseases
General Presentation
Background: It is not uncommon for children to present with fractures after experiencing trauma. However, children may also present with pathological fractures, which are fractures that occur in abnormal bones and typically occur during routine activity or after minor trauma. It is important to be able to distinguish between traumatic fractures and pathological fractures as the prognosis and treatment can vary quite considerably. One also MUST consider non-accidental injury in the child that presents with multiple unexplained fractures. Non-accidental injuries are discussed in a separate article on this site.
These fractures will generally present as localized pain and tenderness over the involved bone. Refusal to weight bear in the younger, non-verbal child is also very common.
Pathophysiology: Although there are many potential etiologies for weakened bone manifesting as pathological fractures, it is simple to divide it into three categories with common etiologies:
1) Metabolic bone disease- eg. Rickets
2) Bone tumours – eg. Benign tumours (non-ossifying fibroma and osteochondroma) and malignant tumours (osteosarcoma and Ewing’s sarcoma)
3) Connective tissue bone disease- eg. Osteogenesis imperfecta
Metabolic Bone Disease: Normal bone growth and mineralization requires adequate calcium and phosphate. There are numerous etiologies of rickets, including nutritional deficiencies (calcium, phosphate and vitamin D), drug induced, renal pathology, and tumours. The end result and clinical manifestations of rickets are secondary to the failure of calcification of the growth plate cartilage because of a deficiency of either calcium or phosphate. Rickets is defined as deficient mineralization at the bone’s growth plate whereas osteomalacia refers to impaired mineralization of the bone matrix. Rickets is relatively common in children, especially those who have poor dietary intake, poor absorption, increased excretion of calcium, phosphate, or vitamin D, premature infants or breast-fed infants who are not supplemented with vitamin D. Regardless of whether it is calcium or phosphate deficient rickets, the typical clinical findings associated with Rickets include:
- Skeletal Findings(see Figure 1):
- Delayed closure of the fontanelle
- Parietal and frontal bossing
- Craniotabes (soft skull bones)
- Rachitic rosary (enlargement of the costochondral junction such that there is beading across the anterolateral aspects of the chest)
- Widening of the wrists; bowing the distal radius and ulna
- Progressive bowing of the femur and tibia
- Extraskeletal Findings(vary depending on the primary mineral deficiency):
- Calcipenic rickets – hypoplasia of dental enamel, decreased muscle tone, delayed achievement of motor milestones, hypocalcemic seizures, increased sweating
- Phosphopenic rickets – dental abscesses
Bone Tumors: Tumours, regardless of whether they are benign or malignant, can cause pathological fractures by growing and replacing the normal tissue of bone. This results in an abnormal, weakened bone more prone to fractures. In children, benign bone tumours are fairly common, but are often asymptomatic and discovered incidentally during evaluation for trauma or another condition, and thus, the true incidence is unknown. If they are symptomatic, they may present with localized pain, swelling, deformity or a pathological fracture. Most benign tumours generally present during the second decade. Two examples of common benign tumours which can present as pathological fractures include non-ossifying fibroma, and osteoid osteomas.
Malignant bone tumours account for 5% of all pediatric malignancies, with the peak occurrence between the ages of 10-24. The two most common malignant bone tumours in children are Ewing’s sarcoma and osteosarcoma which collectively make up 90% of the pediatric bone tumours. Ewing’s sarcoma is more common within the first 10 years, and then osteosarcoma becomes more common. The cancers often arise in the pelvis, femur, tibia and humerus. These can commonly present with symptoms of pain and swelling, which may be worse with exercise or at night, and sometimes the first signs may be due to a pathological fracture.
Connective Tissue Disease: Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is an inherited connective tissue disorder commonly known as “brittle bone disease” which can manifest in a wide spectrum, from mild to lethal forms. It is usually due to a deficiency of normal Type I collagen, which is an organic component necessary for proper bone formation. Although its incidence is estimated to approximately 0.005%, it is important to include this disease in the differential diagnosis because it can present early in children as numerous and recurrent pathological fractures. The common clinical manifestations of OI include:
- Multiple and/or atypical fractures
- Short stature
- Scoliosis
- Basilar skull deformities
- Wormian bones (irregular, small bones along the cranial sutures)
- Blue sclera
- Hearing loss
- Opalescent teeth that wear quickly
- Increased laxity of ligaments and skin
- Easy bruising
- Accelerated osteoporosis
Questions to Ask
- How did the fracture occur – How, when, where? – to determine if it was pathological or traumatic fracture
- Has the child had any previous fractures or any other concurrent fractures? If so, can you describe them? – to help determine pathological versus traumatic fracture
- What is the child’s diet like? To determine if nutritional deficiency Rickets may be the cause
- Did the child have any previous bone pain? If so, can you describe what makes it better or worse? Also, does it get worse at night? To check for potential bone tumors
- Does the child have a fever? To rule out any potential infectious causes or malignancies (constitutional symptoms – fevers, weight loss, drenching night sweats)
- Does the child have any other medical history? To rule out a secondary cause of the bone disease
- Do you suspect that the child may have been abused? Who is the primary caretaker of the child?
- Is the child taking any other medications?
Differential Diagnosis for Pathological Fracture
- Rickets from Vitamin D deficiency
- Osteogenesis Imperfecta
- Renal Osteodystrophy
- Osteomyelitis
- Child abuse
- Preterm birth resulting in osteopenia – neonates
- Fibrous dysplasia
- Osteomalacia
- Copper deficiency – infants: first 6 months
- Bone tumours and cancers
- Chronic Vitamin A toxicity
- Metabolic diseases – leading to calcium wasting and demineralization
- Prolonged administration of prostaglandins, glucocorticoids, or methotrexate
- Congenital syphilitic periostitis
- Hypophospatasia
- Juvenile Osteoporosis
Investigations and Management
1) Rickets:
Laboratory findings:
- Elevated alkaline phosphatase – indication of impaired bone mineralizeation
- Serum phosphorous concentrations – usually low in hypocalcemic and hypophosphatemic rickets
- Serum calcium concentration – decreased only in hypocalcemic rickets
- Parathyroid hormone – usually elevated in hypocalcemic rickets, but usually normal in hypophosphatemic rickets
- 25-OH Vitamin D – low in vitamin D deficiency
- GFR and Creatinine – to determine kidney function
Radiographic Findings:
- Osteopenia
- Metaphyseal cupping and fraying (See Figure 2)
- Physeal widening
- Enlargement of costochondral junction
- Bowing of long bones (See Figure 3)
Management:
- Oral doses of 5,000-15,000 IU/day of Vitamin for 4 weeks for Vitamin deficient Rickets
- Optimize calcium intake for hypocalcemic rickets
- Treat underlying primary cause of Rickets
2) Bone Tumors (benign and malignant)
Laboratory Findings:
- If suspect malignancy: blood work including liver enzymes, CT chest, bone scan, bone biopsy, MRI of affected bone
Radiographic Findings:
- Benign: single lesion generally, sharp area of delineation, overlying cortex intact, sclerotic margins, no or simple periosteal reaction (See Figure 4)
- Malignant: multiple lesions often, poor delineation of lesion, loss of overlying cortex, extensive periosteal reaction, potential soft tissue involvement (See Figure 5)
Management:
- Benign: follow up with radiographs 4-6 months later
- Malignant: complete resection, chemotherapy, radiation
3) Osteogenesis Imperfecta
Laboratory Findings:
- Elevated levels of serum alkaline phosphatase
- Hypercalciuria – magnitude reflects severity of disease
- C-terminal peptide (marker of bone formation) and C-telopeptide (marker of bone resorption) –can be higher
Radiographic Findings:
- Mild OI: Thin cortex and relatively few fractures with normal skull development
- More severe OI: hyperplastic callus formation (from thickened periosteum), shortened long bones with multiple fractures (See see Figure 6)
Management:
- Bisphosphonates
Conclusion
Children who present with pathological fractures always require a thorough evaluation. It is important to keep an open mind as to the various causes of pathologic fractures and to always rule out non-accidental injury.
References
1) Beary J, Chines A. Clinical features and diagnosis of osteogenesis imperfecta. (Last Updated June 15, 2010) In: UpToDate, Tepas E (Ed), UpToDate, Wellesley, MA, 2010.
2) Scheri S. Differential diagnosis of the orthopedic manifestations of child abuse. (Last Updated Dec. 3, 2008) In: UpToDate, Wiley E (Ed), UpToDate, Wellesley, MA, 2010.
3) Rauch F. Overview of Rickets in Children. (Last Updated August 11, 2010). In: UpToDate, Hoppin A (Ed), UpToDate, Wellesley, MA, 2010.
4) Tis J. Overview of benign bone tumors in children and adolescents. (Last Updated September 28, 2010) In: UpToDate, Torchia, M (Ed), UpToDate, Wellesley, MA, 2010.
5) Kliegman R, Behrman, Jenson H, Stanton B. Nelson Textbook of Pediatrics, 18th ed. Philadelphia: Saunders, 2007.
6) Benson M, Fixsen J, Macnicol M. Children’s Orthopaedics and Fractures, 3rd ed. New York: Springer, 2010.
7) Kirpalani A, Babyn P. Imaging in Osteogenesis Imperfecta. eMedicine (Last Updated August 5, 2008). Available from http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/411919-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011]
8) Rijn R, McHugh K. Rickets Imaging. eMedicine (Last Updated March 18, 2009). Available fromhttp://emedicine.medscape.com/article/412862-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011]
9) Dugani S, and Lam D. Toronto Notes. Toronto Notes Medical Publishing Inc. 2009
10) Jenny C. Evaluating Infants and Young Children with Multiple Fractures. Pediatrics. 2006; 118(3):1299-303.
11) Adam A, Dixon A. Adam: Grainger & Allison’s Diagnostic Radiology, 5th ed. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone, An Imprint of Elsevier, 2008.
Acknowledgements
Written by: Teresa Liang
Edited by: Anne Marie Jekyll, MD (Pediatric Resident)
Images
(Image from Rijn R, McHugh K. Rickets Imaging. eMedicine (Last Updated March 18, 2009). Available fromhttp://emedicine.medscape.com/article/412862-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011])
(Image from Rijn R, McHugh K. Rickets Imaging. eMedicine (Last Updated March 18, 2009). Available fromhttp://emedicine.medscape.com/article/412862-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011])
(Image from Rijn R, McHugh K. Rickets Imaging. eMedicine (Last Updated March 18, 2009). Available fromhttp://emedicine.medscape.com/article/412862-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011])
(Adapted from Adam A, Dixon A. Adam: Grainger & Allison’s Diagnostic Radiology, 5th ed. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone, An Imprint of Elsevier, 2008)
(Adapted from Adam A, Dixon A. Adam: Grainger & Allison’s Diagnostic Radiology, 5th ed. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone, An Imprint of Elsevier, 2008)
(Image from Kirpalani A, Babyn P. Imaging in Osteogenesis Imperfecta. eMedicine (Last Updated August 5,2009). Available from http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/411919-print [Accessed on March 5, 2011])
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)